
I grew up with the idea that the size of my body was the most important thing in the world—and that my body was always too large.
When I look back at pictures, I see me at normal, chubby, and large—but at no time did I ever see myself as anything but too big and in need of a diet. Every bite I took was measured in self-worth and whether I could afford the calories, or deserved them.
The answer was always a resounding no.
When I received the ‘first pass corrections’ for Waisted (the layout that comes before the final printing) I looked at the first line— Everyone hates a fat woman— and remembered every time I felt those words.
I think I’ve been holding that first line as an opening to a novel since I began writing.
We’re a harsh country when it comes to issues around size—filled with both self-loathing and a Calvinist push towards walking off, dieting away, running from, and when all else fails, surgically sucking out unwanted fat.
Do men suffer as women do? I’m not sure—not when fat men on the screen can bed and wed the loveliest of women; film and television reversals are unlikely. I believe being fat is painful for men. I simply don’t think they’re as reviled; they need to climb far higher up the scale to merit as much hate as heavy women.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
In this provocative, wildly entertaining, and compelling novel, a group of women enrolled in an extreme weight loss documentary discovers self-love and sisterhood as they enact a daring revenge against the exploitative filmmaker’s owners.
Alice and Daphne, both successful working mothers, both accomplished and seemingly steady, harbor the same secret: obsession with their weight overshadows concerns about their children, husbands, work—and everything else of importance in their lives. Scales terrify them.
Daphne, plump in a family of model-thin women, learned only slimness earns admiration at her mother’s knee. Alice, break-up skinny when she met her husband, risks losing her marriage if she keeps gaining weight.
The two women meet at Privation. Located in a remote Vermont mansion, the program promises fast, dramatic weight loss, and Alice, Daphne, and five other women are desperate enough to leave behind their families for this once in a lifetime opportunity. The catch? They must agree to always be on camera; afterward, the world will see Waisted: The Documentary
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
I recently re-read (even re-bought, when I couldn’t find my copy) Food and Loathing by Betsy Lerner. From far too young, Lerner’s existence rested on her body size—real and perceived.
The book begins thusly:
“It is 1972. I am twelve years old. It is the first day of sixth grade, and I am standing in the girls’ gymnasium waiting to be weighed.”
If your flesh doesn’t crawl with those words, if you don’t want to either go running for a cream cheese smothered bagel, or conversely, vow to stop eating as of tomorrow, you may have grown up with a better sense of self-worth than Betsy or I.
The hatred of our flesh often has no bearing in reality. One of my best friends in the world begins each day pinching her flesh with callipered fingers and living for her daily-rationed cookie. She is tight and muscled and yet lives each day as though a sorcerer might drop fifty pounds on her at any moment.
Do I understand this?
I do.
I grew up with a thin mother who lived for leanness and beauty. My sister’s body mirrored hers. To the day she died at eighty, my mother would ask, “how’s your weight” each time we spoke, as though my ‘weight’ was a living-breathing entity separate from that which she liked about me.

Trying to hold in the stomach my mother hated, I sloughed her words off with sarcasm and sighs; still my life was frozen in moments: My mother hiding cookies in a pot on the top of the cabinets. (I got exercise climbing up.) Swiping the icing from the middle of the Entenmann’s cake until the double layered thing became thinner and thinner (but not me.)
I remember the horror of looking for a dress for my cousin’s Bar Mitzvah as my mother rolled her eyes and complained to the saleswomen about her disgust at the lack of gowns into which I could zip. Last week I had to search for old family photos for an article. While doing so, I came across a picture of me at the Bar Mitzvah, wearing the gown.

Fourteen and thinking I was huge. I truly needed that champagne.
This was the ‘me’ that wanted to die from being so fat. I can’t believe I suffered as I did.
Of course, I found pictures where I was a bit plump. Truthfully, pictures where I am plain old fat. Even now it’s close to impossible to put them up. But I’ll put up a small collage here. And try to remember that I wasn’t deserving of loathing when I was fat. And yet I felt that I was–and by some, I truly was hated for the size of my body. Especially by myself. Despite being the same person.

We’re hated, we hate ourselves, and we learn to sneak our food. I devoured cookies that I hid in the bathroom hamper.
The minute I put this collage up, I wanted to stuff cake in my mouth. I And none of these are me at my heaviest. I probably tore them all up.
Betsy Lerner joined Overeaters Anonymous in junior high, where she learned to divide food into forbidden and good. She became either a compulsive eater or a compulsive dieter, depending on the day, the month, and the moment. When binging, real life was always a day away. When dieting, she considered herself abstinent.
Food and Loathing is not a self-help book; it’s no guide for losing weight. Nor is it a companionable hug for staying heavy. It’s a mirror. It’s looking back, looking forward, or looking at who you are right this moment.
After finishing it, I thought (not for the first time, not for the last) about how much space I want to rent in my head to the mirror and to the scale. Right now, at this moment, this day, this week, this month, this minute, I am sorta okay, and that’s probably okay. I think that perhaps, sorta-okay is as good as it gets with acceptance for some of us.
When you grow up with hamper cookies and sighs, getting to sorta-okay when you look in the mirror can be a damned miracle.

Thank you for sharing that with us. I’ve struggled with my weight my whole life..peaking at about 200 lbs about 20 years ago..,at 5’1” I was obese. I lost weight and kept it off, then it would creep up again, and a few years I finally ended up in a good place physically and mentally. It’s a very difficult, sensitive subject.
Thanks, Susan–sounds like we’ve had a very similar up and down. Can’t wait to see you at another event!!!
I grew u normal until I decided I was too fat and went on a starvation diet. I avoided my mother’s eyes and her grimaces when I ate something she disapprove of. I went down 79 pounds and I was 5 ft 2 inches. it became an agony. I was always hungry and always starving. I played sports and smoked cigarettes. finally, when I began stealing food, I knew I needed help. what a pain in the neck! Having an eating disorder is a bitch.
chat with pat
Thanks so much for sharing this, Pat! Weight obsession is a damned bitch.
I lost 140 pounds as a result of bariatric surgery 5 years ago. I still see myself at 265 pounds rather than my current healthy weight. When people tell me I look good, all I can see are my flaws. When I lost the weight I would get furious when men now paid attention to me. I was the same person inside, just wrapped in a different package post weight loss. Women are extremely hard on themselves and other women based on their weight. We all need to learn to love ourselves for who we are, not what size we are.
I know what you mean. I’ve lost weight over the past few years–but when people say complimentary things, I think they’re making fun of me — even as I know they wouldn’t do that.
I can’t wait to read it! I remember attending a Saturday class at Grub Street with you when you talked about the seed of this novel. Good for you and for us fans.
Rosemary Porto “the Other Girl from Brooklyn”
Thank you, Rosemary! I hope to see you at an event!!!
I had a weight problem from age 8 to 16, then went from 175 to 114 in 5 months. I have obsessed about my weight for years – I rarely enjoy eating, and when I do, feel guilty. My whole life has more of less been defined by weight. I look forward to reading this book.
I feel you 100%, Marianne. I can’t think of a single piece of food I put into my mouth without thinking or guilting. And let’s not even talk about the scale obsessions.
Truly resonates..thank you for writing. A coworker nurse, some years back, was obsessed with weight control, took mail order diet pills and died of a heart attack , leaving 3 little girls. I can relate to all of your feelings and emotions, and try now to be more sensible…not easy!
That’s such a sad story–and I so understand it. The lengths to which we will go is indescribable. Not easy at all. Thanks, Darlene.
Just read this. Trying not to cry because I have to go to work soon. My whole life right here. Sad and angry, feeling judged by my size—as if that were my worth. Sometimes I believed them. Shopping for clothes as a child and now: holy hell. And when I look back at photos, I wasn’t even that fat. What a waste of a psyche. Girls had it much harder in this tegard but boys suffer too. That you for writing this.
To this day, I can’t fathom how my life revolves around that square piece of metal in my bathroom. And yet it does. We feel each other, Susan.
My deceased narcissist ex-husband literally told me that he was perfectly justified in having affairs during our marriage because I betrayed him by gaining weight therefore he betrayed me because I gained weight. I have battled weight issues all of my life. The contempt my family and I had for my body was deep and painful. My family’s alleged compliment to me was, “You’re just so beautiful, if you’d just lose forty pounds. How the fuq* the idiots thought that was a compliment to a teenaged girl was amazing. These were all highly educated people making this comments. My hard working single mother honestly thought she said nothing wrong. I learned to stay away from my family for years and when I realized I had a panic attack planning a trip to see them one year, I determined enough was enough unfortunately and took my daughters back to visit my mother where the weight commentary was too much. I never returned and she passed from cancer and I never did go visit her.
Erin, the bandwidth taken up by the damage done (wittingly or unwittingly) by our family is wider than can be measured. Sending you loads of love and peace.